All Radar picks

X OPPORTUNITY RADAR / THE SCORECARD

The Aid Budget Wasn’t Big Enough to Finance the Rearmament Anyway

SIPRI finds rich states are cutting development aid while military budgets surge. The savings are small beside the rearmament bill, but large enough to wreck the programs being cut.

Information Overload
3 min readSources
AI-generated conceptual editorial illustration of a government budget balance with a narrow, fraying conveyor carrying medical, water and relief supplies while a much larger red-lit conveyor carries military equipment and stacks of appropriations. No real facility or procurement program is depicted.
AI-generated conceptual editorial illustration. It is not a chart and does not depict measured quantities.

The fiscal alibi does not balance

SIPRI researchers Xiao Liang and Nan Tian compare military expenditure and official development assistance across OECD Development Assistance Committee states. Their central finding is awkward for governments selling aid cuts as a way to finance defense: the savings from those cuts are modest relative to planned military-spending increases.[1]

ODA fell to $174 billion in 2025, down 23 percent from 2024 in constant prices, according to the OECD data used by the paper. The authors also strip out aid to Ukraine and in-donor refugee costs to show that core development assistance had already begun stagnating before the headline reversal.[1]

Meanwhile, the paper puts global military spending at $2.9 trillion in 2025. Rearmament is a policy choice with its own fiscal scale. Development aid is not secretly the aircraft-carrier fund.[1][2]

A widening needs gap

The paper builds a needs index from ten variables covering conflict, displacement, disasters, poverty and development conditions. It then estimates how donor commitments historically responded to those needs.[1]

In the baseline scenario, the model projects needs-adjusted ODA of $262 billion in 2028 against expected commitments of about $147 billion, a $115 billion gap. In the higher-needs scenario, the gap reaches $179 billion. Even the lower-needs scenario leaves a $27 billion shortfall. These modeled 2028 amounts are expressed in constant 2024 U.S. dollars.[1]

Those figures are modeled benchmarks, not invoices for fully meeting global need. The authors say the historical donor response was already insufficient. Their method estimates what aid might look like if the old relationship between need and commitments continued.[1]

Our read

Governments have found a tidy story: the world is dangerous, therefore the humanitarian line item must report for duty by disappearing. SIPRI’s numbers show the arithmetic is mostly theater.

Cutting aid does not finance the rearmament surge in any meaningful sense. It does remove health, infrastructure and crisis funding from places where a comparatively small reduction can carry outsized consequences. Then policymakers get to rediscover instability later as a security emergency, with uniforms and a larger invoice.[1]

Military spending and aid are not interchangeable tools, and real threats do require defense. The point is narrower and harder to dodge: leaders should defend each budget choice on its own merits instead of pretending a small development cut is the fiscal engine of a huge military expansion.

Caveat: The forward gaps come from a needs-based econometric model, not direct costed assessments of every program. The model has no unaffected comparison group, relies on historical donor behavior that the authors describe as inadequate, and uses scenarios rather than forecasts. The project was funded by the Gates Foundation, an institutional interest worth keeping visible. SIPRI’s descriptive spending series and its modeled future gaps should not be treated as the same kind of evidence.[1]

CORRECTIONS & UPDATES.

Update ·
Clarified that the modeled 2028 aid amounts are expressed in constant 2024 U.S. dollars.

FOLLOW THE SOURCES.

Checked Oct 30, 2026. Numbered references point to the evidence behind factual passages. Commentary is our own.

  1. Rising Military Spending in the Context of Falling Development Assistance (opens in a new tab)SIPRIBack to cited passage
  2. Global aid gap widens as major donors prioritize higher military spending (opens in a new tab)SIPRIBack to cited passage
GeopoliticsMilitary spendingDevelopment aidHuman security
Back to the latest picks